This morning Amazon, in conjunction with Penguin Books and Publishers Weekly, announced the winners of the second round. From an initial 10,000 submissions (see the previous post for details on that), it has now been narrowed down to 250 selections in each of the categories (General Fiction and Young Adult).
“Brothers In Darkness” made it!
Some readers may be asking, “Beyond making your day, what does qualifying for round three mean?”
The answer: I’ll be getting a full book review from “Publisher’s Weekly“!
“Publishers Weekly will then read the Quarter-Finalists’ full Manuscripts to rate and review them based on five Judging Criteria: originality of idea, plot, prose/writing style, character development, and overall strength of submission.”
I’ve also been fortunate enough to get two early round reviews from Amazon. These are based only on the first 5,000 words of the book (about twenty pages). For those who’ve already read the book, the final bit of the initial excerpt is:
“‘Choose one of these three rings, Mr. Crichton. Tell me which Ring has power.’
He motioned to my desk, and I realized three rings sat there. Three identical rings, each an exact match for the one in the photo, sitting less than a foot from my hands. Looking at them, they were the same. I picked them up, one at a time. And I knew. I could feel it. One ring, it was dead. I felt nothing. One was weak, but there was something there. And the third, the third Ring had power. It was… it wanted me. It wanted to be worn. I needed to put on that Ring. And I did.“
********************************************************************************
Excerpt Review #1:
ABNA Expert Reviewer
What is the strongest aspect of this excerpt?
The voice of the author, the writing style is very strong, original, crisp, current day patois. The introduction of the protagonist is extremely clever, lively and seductive. It drew me in. The emergence of all facts in the case is carefully planned to not be flat footed. The woman’s face being considerably older than her husband’s picture is fascinating. The electric shock when Crichten puts the key in the lock is totally unexpected and shocking for the reader as well. The revelation that The Brothers aren’t actually speaking, but are inside his head is good.
What aspect needs the most work?
The path into the creature’s mouth is a little too long. The fight with the monster becomes dull and ponderous and overdone with synonyms for bad and scary. Here, I think the author pulled out a thesaurus and gutted it. Plus, the transition into the monster segment is too abrupt. I didn’t get it for a few sentences.
What is your overall opinion of this excerpt?
It’s very original , not only in the overall concept but in individual ideas throughout and writing style. It’s exciting. It’s terrific. I enjoyed reading it and want to read the rest of it. I want to meet this guy, the author and the protagonist. As a Portlandian I appreciate references to my fine and famous city.
**********************************************************************************
Excerpt Review #2:
ABNA Expert Reviewer
What is the strongest aspect of this excerpt?
The excerpt does a fine job of setting up the plot and tone of the novel to follow. The first scene, with Mrs. McMillan, has a gritty detective story feel with only hints of the supernatural, while what follows at the house introduces a seemingly inexplicable horror, and the rest of the excerpt brings dark fantasy into the equation and makes clear the dual conflict that will presumably drive the plot of this novel and possible sequels: Crichton’s effort to recover the ring (and other such objects) on the one hand, and his uncertainty and frustration about working with the Brothers on the other. The players and the stakes of the story are just beginning to become clear, which makes readers eager to learn more, to find out what happens next.
What aspect needs the most work?
What the excerpt needs now is a greater emphasis on the character of Lucas, whose personality and habits are too much a mystery. Obviously that’s the intention, for his secrets to be revealed over time, but the reader needs a little more to hold on to at the beginning if Lucas is going to be at all sympathetic or interesting. Hints of his past, the reason he’s living under an assumed name, what he’s given up in living like that, could be seeded throughout this excerpt to increase the sense of mystery and make the reader intensely curious about Lucas’ past as well as his future.
In addition to more about his past, the excerpt could also benefit from additional detail about Lucas’ present. How does he live? Does he have hobbies, something to fill up his time, or is his life simply a matter of day-to-day survival? What effect have his decisions had on his personality? Is he always as grim as he seems in the excerpt, or are there times when the clouds lift? Does he have quirks that would go against reader expectations? In the present excerpt, Lucas feels a bit too much like a generic gritty-detective type, and readers will relate to him better if his richness as a character is more immediately obvious.
A final way to improve the character would be to inject more humor into his voice. The pitch mentions elements of humor and witty dialogue, but the excerpt doesn’t seem to show much of that (although the Elmer Fudd reference is nice). Giving Lucas one-liners and other comedy that fits his personality would be an easy way to get the reader on his side early on.
What is your overall opinion of this excerpt?
This is a solid excerpt by a writer with an excellent sense of pace and some skill at balancing different modes (horror, fantasy, mystery) in the service of a cross-genre story. Although the elements of mystery and fantasy involved are traditional, the interplay among them and the touches of horror give the excerpt a chance of “hooking” the reader. That sense of the traditional, however, coupled with the somewhat broad characterization of Lucas, means that the excerpt doesn’t set itself apart from the similar fare with which it’s competing as much as it might. Since it would be difficult to rearrange the plot at this stage, the best way to combat that familiar atmosphere would be to reveal, or at least hint at, the things that make Lucas a unique hero. Emphasizing his past, personality, and/or voice could give the excerpt the advantage it needs to stand out from the crowd.
**************************************************************************************************************
I can’t wait for the Publisher’s Weekly review! Having the chance to get a real critique from a respected industry magazine is a rare and valuable opportunity that I’m very grateful for. Wish me luck!
Like this:
Like Loading...